Back HexScope Lens

85% Of AI Brand Mentions Come From Other Sites. Start With The Comparison Posts

POINT Key points
  • Nearly 90% of third-party mentions trace to listicles, comparisons and reviews
  • On those pages, 80% of brands often appear among the first three named

“We Fixed The Site. So Why Doesn’t ChatGPT Name Us?”

You tidy up the FAQ, add structured data, and rewrite the official information so an AI can read it easily. You do all of that, ask ChatGPT, and the company name still doesn’t come up. I’ve been hearing that a lot lately. The FAQ went in. The structured data went in.

The direction of the work looks right, so why doesn’t the name appear?

AirOps, a company that sells AI-visibility tools, published a report in October 2025 that collected 21,311 brand mentions from the answers of three AI assistants and counted where each one came from (report).

Where Do AI Assistants Get What They Say About Brands?

Mostly from outside the brand’s own site: for questions asked while shopping around, more than 80% of the brand mentions in those AI answers came from somewhere else. Mentions that came through third-party sites outnumbered mentions through the brand’s own domain 6.5 to 1.

In plain numbers, 85% came from external domains. The share picked up directly from the brand’s own domain was 13.2%.

The answers counted were the ones GPT-5, Claude Sonnet 4.5 and Perplexity Sonar gave to more than 500 .

The report says it covered six industries; the ones it names are MarTech (marketing software), Sales, HR/Finance and Productivity/Collaboration.

So what kind of pages do those outside mentions come from?

Nearly Nine In Ten Outside Mentions Come From Pages That Compare And Rate Products

Of the third-party mentions, nearly 90% came from a listicle (a “best tools for X” list post), a comparison or a review. Pages that line products up and rate them seem to be the main way into an AI’s answer.

And of the brands those pages picked up, 80% often appeared among the first three companies the piece discussed, apparently.

So the AIs may tend to pick up the brands near the top of the pages they cite. But the report doesn’t say how many companies each piece listed. On a list of five, landing in the first three isn’t unusual to begin with, so there’s no way to tell how lopsided that 80% really is. Nor does the report test whether moving up the list is what gets you into the answer.

Each Assistant Sees A Different Cast Of Brands

About 68% of brands were seen in only one of the three AIs. Taken one assistant at a time, 37% to 52% of the brands each one named never came up in the other two.

One AI isn’t enough. Your name turning up in one assistant doesn’t mean it turns up in the others.

It’s a bit like asking the same question in three bookshops and finding a completely different stack of books on the front table in each one. This was the point where I came back, again, to the need to look across several AIs at once.

How Far The 85% Reaches

AirOps sells AI-visibility tools, so it has a commercial stake in the conclusion pointing toward “outside mentions matter.” With that on the table, these are the conditions to keep in mind before applying the numbers to your own brand:

  • The report’s example questions are all in English and cover commercial-intent questions in six industries only; other languages and industries are still untested
  • The three buckets (“own domain,” “external domain,” “no source shown”) each get a one-line definition, and the report doesn’t spell out where the boundaries between them fall
  • The report came out in October 2025, and the way each AI cites sources may have changed since

Even so, the direction (a large share of the talk about a brand happens off its own site) works as a guide for deciding where to look next.

So Go Find Yourself In The Comparison Posts

Keeping your own site in order is still the groundwork you need. But only 13.2% of the mentions were picked up from the brand’s own domain, a little over one in ten. Maybe nobody is watching the rest yet.

The easiest place to start is to find one comparison post or list post that has your company’s name in it, and check how it describes you and about where in the order you sit. One post is plenty for a first pass.

Could you name three comparison posts that mention your company right now? Next time I take stock, I’m putting this comparison-post check at the top of the list, alongside the checks on our own site.

Widen Where You Look Past Your Own Site

For questions asked while shopping around, more than 80% of the brand mentions in AI answers come from outside the brand’s own site. And nearly 90% of that outside share comes from pages built to line products up and rate them: comparison posts, list posts, reviews. The ways in are narrower than you might expect.

Fixing your own site and knowing how you’re described elsewhere are two separate jobs, and both need to move. If you want another count of what AIs lean on when they cite, from a different angle, there’s the finding that seven to nine in ten of the news sites that blocked AI crawlers were still being cited.

How a comparison post writes you up sits outside any redesign of your own site. This month, find one comparison post that lists you and jot down a single line on how it describes you and where you’re placed.

Then, when you open the same post next month, you’ll see straight away whether the way it treats you has changed.

Sources

Share this article
Bluesky X
Back to all articles